you're reading...

Thoughts While Mowing: Is Education the Most Important Thing or Not?

Today while mowing the lawn I listened to two podcasts that just happened to be centered around education.  First was the TED Radio Hour, hosted by Guy Raz.  It was really interesting and was focused on Unstoppable Learning.  If you teach please click here and listen!

The talk that stood out the most this morning was with Sugata Mitra – his talk was how kids can teach themselves.  It was really interesting and to briefly sum up: children in rural India taught themselves English and how to interact with a computer and do some research, all without an adult to guide them.  It was very interesting, so interesting that I made it easy for you to see:

After watching/listening to this I was thinking over a couple of questions inside my mind: how often do I get in my own way, and why do we take education for granted in the United States?  Do we take it for granted?  Education is a basic right for every human.  Yet we don’t treat it that way.  Maybe that is okay…

As a society (American point of view) it is difficult to imagine not having education as part of our children’s lives.  We expect it.  Our children expect it.  Yet we don’t give it all we can give.  Look at the joy these young children have as they learn – do our young children look at learning like this?  If not, why?

If you don’t believe me, then look at the investment that we make in education – we don’t.  In Oklahoma, we have cut classes and increased class size due to funding issues.  Those that create policy at the state and federal level just assume that any old person can teach, no matter the training they have had.

Turns out – maybe they are on to something – Sugata doesn’t think that the adult part is necessary.  He does provide a way to learn and he does let the children explore, he does not have a national curriculum.  How can we create an environment where children just dig in to learn something?

Maybe our system is outdated.  Maybe we should shift our focus off of narrow curriculums and bubble in assessments.  Maybe we should try a totally open education – students learn what they want when they want…Maybe we are in our own way…

Definitely food for thought…

The podcast that followed was Freakonomics hosted by Stephen Dubner and he had an interview with Harvard President Drew Gilpin Faust, you can listen to it here.  She is the first female president of Harvard and the interview was very interesting.

Here is the transcript of the part of the conversation that resonated with me – emphasis is mine:

DUBNER: There’s a lot of evidence, particularly in the realm of economics, that the ROI, the return on investment, on education is very strong. In fact, one could argue that education is maybe the single best investment that any human could ever make in oneself or in one family. But increasingly there’s been a lot of suspicion and indeed, some evidence that the ROI is either declining, or simply not as strong as believed, and/ or that too many people have been directed toward a certain kind of colleges when in fact that perhaps might not be best for their outcome. How do you look at that question? Please be as empirical as you can in making the argument that education is indeed the great investment that universities argue it is.

FAUST: Well, what we’ve seen in the past decade or two is that knowledge is increasingly the currency of the world in which we operate. And the differential between what a high school graduate can make over a lifetime and what a college graduate makes over a lifetime has increased. We also saw during the recession that unemployment was much lower among college graduates than it was under those who did have college degrees. So this is a time when learning and knowledge is increasingly, not decreasingly, important. This is something that we need to recognize as a society, and Harvard believes very strongly in this, and believes in giving opportunity to students from the widest possible range of backgrounds and financial circumstances. But we need to think about this holistically as a system of higher education across the United States. And the importance of the publics, who have been significantly defunded. In about the 1990s, one in four dollars of support for the publics came from families. And the rest came from the state. This has reversed. And so when you see the cost of education in the publics has not changed but the price has changed because they have been defunded by their state governments. This is a disinvestment that our nation is making in the most important investment it can make in its future. And so we need to make sure that places like Harvard can thrive. But we also need to make sure that the publics can thrive, and the system of community colleges as well for students who are seeking either a leg up into a four-year college education, or perhaps a terminal two-year degree that will give them the skills to operate within the modern technologically advanced workforce.

I wonder if we truly believe this?  Is education the most important investment that we can make?  If it is not, then what should be our priority?  What can we do to change our view of education?  I know that it can be difficult to fund necessary things during a recession, but I think we have mostly moved out of that.

What can we do with policy to make sure that there is funding for education, yet not unnecessarily taxing citizens?  Is this possible?  Will a flat tax work? Do we need to re-examine the funding formula from top to bottom?  Education systems have really cut out the fluff, can they budget more wisely?  How can we make teaching a profession that people want to pursue?  It is clear that right now that is not the case…

Just some thoughts from my head while mowing today…tells you where my brain goes when its just me and myself…and the lawn…


About Scott

My name is Scott. After 18.5 years as a high school math teacher in public education I have made the move to become a full time PhD student. This decisions was difficult, but has been one of the most rewarding things that I have ever done. Teaching in high school was an incredible experience for me, so leaving an environment that I loved for the unknown was a challenge. As I high school teacher, I taught almost every math course that could be offered. I was able to earn National Board Certification in Young Adult Math. I was honored as my building Teacher of the Year, no mean feat at Edmond Memorial High School!! My career changed as I became fascinated with educational technology and all of the things that it can do for teachers. I flipped my class. I used iPads and blogging (in high school math!!). I started using gamification and mastery learning. I changed my practice. I chose to go back to school to learn as much as I could. To bring that knowledge from academia and research to the teacher on the front line. I have had the opportunity to present at several conferences and share what I have learned with others. Its through these connections that we can be the best teachers we can for our students. They deserve it and we sell ourselves short when we don't give it. I love talking with teachers about change. About incorporating educational technology. About the power that they have to change lives. My blog space is me, it shares my passions and frustrations, my joys and my learnings. If you are interested in what I am studying, please visit my graduate school pages. If you are interested in the flipped classroom, I have some links to get your started. I would love to meet you! Do not hesitate to reach out! I would enjoy the opportunity to work with your staff or trade ideas with your teachers - let me know! Have a great day! #BeBrilliant


One thought on “Thoughts While Mowing: Is Education the Most Important Thing or Not?

  1. Thank so much for sharing your considerations that accompanied your lawn mowing. What I’m going to share my first thoughts from my initial efforts to understand and join you and the others in my PLN seeking options to facilitate effective learning for everyone (how’s that for non-ambitious goal???). But that is the goal all of us in education should be pursuing – the one the Harvard president addressed and the one Mitra was working to begin, at least to me.

    What I gained from Mitra was that youngsters will seek to learn, using any options for which they have access. Granted I find their efforts astounding, attaining levels I would not have expected – at least in the time periods they did. But then, it’s even more astounding when you are reminded of the neighborhoods in which they live. My broadest ‘observation group’ is our grandchildren and their friends / classmates here in rural, middle class eastern Connecticut. They too are incredibly curious and creative in their efforts to self-learn about input to play and to understanding topics they’re interested in. Sadly, at this point, I’m wondering if these youngsters are hungry enough to challenge themselves to the levels done in India and elsewhere. I’d like to believe they would, I’ve seen some indication they would… – more Consideration needed!

    This post and its links have not really altered my personal thinking on effective education for youngsters as well as learners of all ages at all levels; effective education is self-controlled efforts to understand topics sufficiently to be able to broaden and deepen that learning as need be, to be able to converse on the topic with people knowing more / having more experience (experts), and – most importantly – be able to utilize that understanding to address situations of real importance. To be clear, beyond the skill of effective learning, that skill will indeed be effective only accompanied by the skills of effective problem solving, working in teams, and communicating at a minimum.

    So there is where an educator, a mentor, a facilitator is so very important. I’m guessing that Mitra’s efforts have shown that people can learn without the formal structure of schools, they obviously work quite well in groups, they do a pretty good job of talking about their efforts. But (I don’t know – at least yet) are all the youngsters in the neighborhood with the computers engaged? Are these youngsters demonstrating any ability to use their learning? I’ll be seeking to better learn about Mitra’s experiments better, especially in these areas. AND if they are doing these things, may I suggest educators as facilitators, mentors, and moderators should be able to help these skills be more effective as they assess and provide feedback on youngsters’ efforts made.

    Here are two key questions that come to mind: (1) Are the Schools of Education provide the experiences for their students consistent with these thoughts? And (2) are the policy and financial people controlling the schools interested in joining this promising (for me at least) approach to ‘formal’ education? With regard to the second question, my current thinking is that funding won’t be the huge issue many think it will be / is… Not convinced money is spent in the right areas at present AND believe the successes will improve the funding request approvals.

    As always, thanks for a great blog post. I truly hope, indeed believe that such thought-provoking pieces such as this contributes to the critical education reform debate!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    Posted by jcbjr9455 | September 6, 2015, 10:05 am

All of the cool people leave comments...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Teaching From Here on WordPress.com

Be amazeballs - enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,630 other followers

Teaching From Here has impacted

  • 31,744 educators and counting.

Teach100 Blogs

Follow me on Twitter @TeachFromHere

Worldwide Impact!

Locations of Site Visitors
%d bloggers like this: